Sometimes the simplest fix is a smaller loan that just covers the arrears, leaving your existing mortgage in place. That’s what a second mortgage can do.

How it works

A second lender registers a loan behind your existing mortgage and pays the arrears directly, bringing your first mortgage up to date. You then make two payments: your regular mortgage and the second mortgage.

When it can make sense

  • The arrears are modest compared with your equity
  • Your first mortgage has a good rate or would be costly to break
  • Your income has recovered and you can handle both payments

The trade-offs

  • Higher cost: second mortgages, especially private ones, carry higher rates and fees
  • Two payments to manage
  • Short terms, often a year, so you need a plan for when it ends

A simple illustration

Round numbers, for illustration only: you’re $9,000 behind on a $280,000 mortgage, on a home worth $450,000. A second mortgage of about $15,000 could cover the arrears, the lender’s fees and legal costs. You’d then pay your regular first mortgage payment plus the second-mortgage payment, perhaps a few hundred dollars a month, for about a year.

What second-mortgage lenders look at

  • Combined equity after both mortgages
  • Why you fell behind and whether it’s resolved
  • Your income now, and whether it supports both payments
  • Your exit plan: how you’ll repay the second mortgage when it matures

Check with your first lender

Some first mortgages restrict second mortgages, and your first lender’s cooperation matters if legal steps have started. Your lawyer should review this.

Plan the exit

At your first mortgage’s renewal, it may be possible to combine both into one mortgage. See refinancing to pay off arrears. Making every payment on time from now on is what makes that possible.

Second mortgage or full refinance?

A second mortgage keeps your existing first mortgage and its rate, and avoids breaking it. A full refinance replaces everything with one payment, but may mean a penalty and a higher rate on the whole balance if a mainstream lender won’t help. For small arrears with a good first mortgage, the second mortgage is often simpler. For larger arrears, or a first mortgage near maturity, a refinance may fit better. See refinancing to pay off arrears.

Questions before you sign

See questions to ask before refinancing.

This article is general information, not financial or legal advice. If you have received a demand letter or court documents, speak to a lawyer.